The Guthrie Inn

Nestled at 1259 Park Ave in New York, The Guthrie Inn is a cocktail bar that has carved out a reputation for its inviting, homey vibe and stellar beverage offerings. Patrons rave about the bar’s atmosphere, describing it as a comfortable blend of worn-in elegance without pretense. Mark Jewell highlights the unique presence of an arcade machine table and shuffleboard, adding a playful twist to the cocktail experience. The drink menu boasts a solid selection of cocktails, alongside basic beers and wines, ensuring there’s something for everyone. Senshi Lion and Brittany Kenyon express their appreciation for the friendly bartenders, who not only create delicious drinks but also foster a welcoming environment. Sharon Pelletier notes the efficiency of service, a testament to the attentive staff who are more than happy to help guests. Arnold Barrios captures the essence of The Guthrie Inn perfectly: it’s a place that feels like home, ideal for a relaxed date night or a lively catch-up with friends. Whether you’re indulging in a classic cocktail or enjoying an espresso martini, The Guthrie Inn promises a delightful evening filled with warmth, conversation, and good vibes. It's definitely a spot worth visiting in the bustling heart of New York City.

Accessibility
- No wheelchair-accessible car park
Service options
- Has outdoor seating
- No delivery
- No takeaway
Highlights
- Has bar games
- Has fast service
- Serves great cocktails
- Good for watching sport
Offerings
- Serves alcohol
- Serves beer
- Serves cocktails
- Serves happy-hour drinks
- Has private dining room
- Serves spirits
- Serves wine
Dining options
- Outside food allowed
- Has seating
Amenities
- Has gender-neutral toilets
- Has toilet
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cosy
- Trendy
Crowd
- Good for groups
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Transgender safe space
Planning
- Accepts reservations
Payments
- Accepts credit cards
- Accepts debit cards
- Accepts NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards

Mark Jewell

May 17,2025

Great little spot with an arcade machine table and shuffleboard. Good selection of cocktails with some basic beers and wines. Definitely worth a visit

Senshi Lion

May 1,2025

Great drinks, great bartender. Always yes to this place

Sharon Pelletier

Apr 3,2025

Comfy vibe of worn-in elegance - loved a cocktail bar that isn’t try-hard. Drinks were fast and delish and the bartender was so friendly and helpful too. (Can bring in your own food.)

Brittany Kenyon

Mar 7,2025

Had a wonderful time last night at The Guthrie Inn grabbing espresso martinis with a friend! The vibe is awesome and the bartenders are so friendly. Great spot to have a drink catch some banter!

Arnold Barrios

Mar 6,2025

If you're looking for a bar with a home like feeling then this is the place. The bartenders are great at making cocktails very friendly not too loud great music, and a great place to take a date.

A K (NYCPerformanceTennis)

Mar 6,2025

Fun little dive-cocktail spot. Very unique for the neighborhood. Sure it's not The Dead Rabbit, or Apotheke, or Attaboy, or Dutch Kills, Fresh Kills, or Little Branch, but what it lacks in stature, it makes up for its simplicity. The cocktails are simple and the ambience is very chill and the staff is very sweet. It's not fancy and pretentious, but it's a cool joint to hang loose. Make sure you get a bite next door @Earl's Beer and Cheese!

Joseph Castano

Feb 27,2025

Matt took great care of my group of 12. Incredible mixologist and great conversation. Highly recommend.

Joel Martinez

Feb 4,2025

What a gem in UES, came with a crew and we all were pleasantly surprise by how chill the place was and the high quality of the cocktails. (Which you can order from and off the menu) The bartender on Saturday night was so friendly and fast, even working alone in a full bar, you can really notice how much he cares about his craft. Definitely be back

Amenities and More

Photos

Reviews For The Guthrie Inn

Add a Review

Location

Appreciated by Others